← Back to the Journal

Seven years to get a hearing

Dylan Foley and I put our names to a simple request in 2019. Travellers should be able to choose who speaks for us. We sent it to the Seanad Public Consultation Committee. We weren’t called to give evidence.

Listen to the full article

English recording · Computer-generated voice

Download the MP3
Earlier English recording

Submission No. 9

Our submission is still there. It’s number nine. Dylan and I proposed an assembly that Travellers would run ourselves. We wanted our own people to choose their representatives. We were ready to go in and discuss how that might work.

Getting in the door

Seven years later, on 7 May 2026, the three of us sat before the Joint Committee on Key Issues affecting the Traveller Community. Dylan came as an archaeologist, Fergus Shanahan as a microbiologist, and I spoke for the TraVision Foundation. After years of asking for a hearing, I thought we had reached the point of it all. We could finally sit down together and have a parley about what should change.

What counts as real life?

Senator Malcolm Noonan was in the chair that day. I appreciated his enthusiasm. He let the conversation run. He asked Dylan what archaeology could tell us about where families had lived. Later he asked how an approach led by the community could take hold. Those were questions we could get our teeth into.

One exchange with Senator Joe O’Reilly stayed with me. He called the discussion fascinating and said the committee’s job was “to try to apply it to real life”. He went on to ask what decisions a Traveller assembly would make. That was a fair question. What disappointed me was the distance I heard between the research on the table and the lives we had come in to talk about.

That disappointed me. Dylan, Fergus and I had come in together because each of us had something to say about Traveller history and identity. To me that was already real life. And we had made a practical proposal seven years earlier. We wanted Travellers to have a say in choosing the people who speak for us. That was what I wanted us to spend time on.

What I said before we left

Towards the end, I reminded the committee that we had sent in our submission in 2019 and had never been called. I also told the members it had been a good experience. I meant that. We got through the door, spoke freely and had a chair who wanted to hear us out. My disappointment was in how much of our time together still went on explaining why this work mattered to everyday life.

The chair said our statements would go into the committee’s work. I’d still ask anyone reading that record to go back to submission No. 9. Seven years before the hearing we had already put a practical proposal on paper. If a committee wants to know what to do with it, my answer is simple enough. Ask Travellers how we want to choose our representatives. Then give the people we choose a seat at the table.

2019 Seanad consultation · Find submission No. 9 under Bernard Sweeney and Dylan Foley (PDF published January 2020)Official hearing, 7 May 2026 · See printed pages 13, 16 and 24 (PDF)